Click here to download a pdf of this article.
Global equity markets climbed the last two trading days of October to finish out an otherwise brutal month. Broad equity indexes around the world were in or near correction territory on October 29, but two strong days eased losses. US stocks fell 6.8% in October, their worst month since September 2011. Foreign equity markets also dropped in October—developed international and emerging-market stocks fell 8.6% and 7.7%, respectively.
The recent volatility in the markets has understandably come with questions, such as, “Is this the start of deeper losses to come?” and if so, “What changes are being made to portfolios?” We don’t know if October is the start of further losses or not. We do know that stocks are volatile and at times go down, despite what we’ve seen over the last nine years. We are confident that the United States will have a recession again that will take most market participants by surprise, and it will correspond with sharper market declines than what we saw last month. Assuming such price declines imply attractive expected future medium- to longer-term returns, we would look at this as an opportunity to add exposure to US stocks.
The wide range of stock market outcomes over brief time periods (see chart below) makes it nearly impossible to predict what will happen next month, next quarter, or next year. And even if you do get it right once and sidestep a large market decline, you have to make another successful timing bet getting back in. We don’t think this is a repeatable investment strategy that would be successful over a long-term investment horizon. In a given 12-month period, US stocks have increased by as much as 61% and fallen as much as 43% since 1950. However, the range of outcomes for stocks narrows the longer an investor’s time horizon. For example, over 20-year periods, the market return has ranged from a positive 6% at the low-end to 18% at the high-end. But to enjoy those positive long-term returns you had to remain disciplined and stay the course during the inevitable painful/scary shorter-term market drops.
In general, we have been moderating the pro-risk bias in our portfolios for most of the year. The market turbulence in October has not led us to make any portfolio changes. There were many negative headlines and lots of things to seemingly be concerned about; however, US stocks only fell about 10% from their highs in September (after rising nearly 400% since March 2009). A 10% drop from all-time highs might have made US stocks attractive for market participants looking to bet on the next quarter or next year, but it has yet to offer an attractive investment opportunity for investors with a five-year (or longer) time horizon.
Beyond the stock market, October may have felt more volatile than usual due to losses in fixed-income markets, which many investors rely on to offset equity losses. US core bonds fell 0.8% in October, while high-yield bonds fell 1.6%. A 60/40 portfolio of US stocks and core bonds fell over 4% in October, which is one of the larger drawdowns in the post–financial crisis period. It remains our expectation that low starting bond yields are unlikely to offset equity market losses to the same extent we’ve historically seen during bear markets. This is one reason why we have maintained below market duration for bond portfolios and continue to seek opportunities in non-traditional investments for many portfolios..
Certain material in this work is proprietary to and copyrighted by Litman Gregory Analytics and is used by Argent Financial with permission. Reproduction or distribution of this material is prohibited and all rights are reserved.