
BY: Jim McElroy
Risk Premiums-an Interpretation
Lately, we’ve noticed more than the usual number of references to “risk premiums” in discussions about the economy and the markets. Risk premiums are being employed to justify, or denounce, investments in stocks, corporate bonds, junk bonds, private credit, private equities … in effect, anything that carries the risk of loss. There’s nothing new about the concept: it’s been a part of investment literature for longer than most of us can remember or indeed than most of us have lived. But the term does seem to appear more frequently during periods of heightened economic stress and uncertainty. And there’s nothing like a war, oil shortages and a new regime at the Federal Reserve to create uncertainty.
At its most basic level, the risk premium is a measure of the extra return one should expect for investing in a risky asset rather than in a riskless asset or “sure thing.” Granted, there’s no such thing as a truly riskless asset, but a U.S. Treasury security is generally considered close enough. As an example, the risk premium for a ten-year corporate bond is its yield to maturity minus the yield to maturity on a ten-year U.S. Treasury bond: a ten-year Baa corporate bond yielding 6.02% has a risk premium of 1.57% over a ten-year U.S. Treasury bond yielding 4.45%. It’s up to the investor to decide whether this extra 1.57% return is worth the risk of default from a low investment-grade bond. For bonds, the calculation of the risk premium is straightforward, so straightforward that bond professionals usually refer to it as the “spread.” For equities, the calculation is a bit more complicated.
Unlike bonds, there are no contractually defined returns for stocks, either in dividend payments or in earnings growth rates. Stock prices are driven by expectations of growth in earnings and, where available, dividends, but there is certainly no guarantee of what those future values might be. All we have is the current price, the current dividend (if any) and the most recent trailing earnings per share. Divide the earnings per share by the current share price and the answer is the earnings yield, which, unsurprisingly, is the inverse of the price-earnings (P/E) ratio. The risk premium for stocks is the earnings yield minus the risk-free rate (as above, the yield to maturity on a ten-year U.S. Treasury bond). Because of the greater uncertainty associated with equity returns—unknown growth rates, uncertain dividend payments, open-ended holding periods—versus the single uncertainty of a bond default, one would expect that the risk premiums for equities would normally exceed the risk premiums for fixed income. However, this is not necessarily the case: over the last one hundred years, Baa corporate bond risk premiums (end-of-year numbers) have exceeded those of the S&P 500 by a score of 55 to 45. This, of course, doesn’t mean that corporate bonds have outperformed stocks over the last one hundred years – that contest hasn’t even been close – but it does mean that over the last one hundred years, on an annual basis, low investment-grade bonds have often appeared to be at least as attractive and sometimes more attractive than large-cap stocks.
In many respects, earnings yields and risk premiums for stocks and bonds are not perfectly comparable. Bond yields and risk premiums can be calculated from data printed in the financial press on a daily basis. Equity earnings yields and risk premiums, however, are based on future forecasts. And those forecasts are constantly in flux. During periods of exuberant optimism, equity markets bid up prices based on earnings growth expectations, driving up P/E ratios and driving down earnings yields. For bond investors, this exuberance translates to a reduced concern for defaults, higher corporate bond prices and lower yields. Much of the difference in risk premiums between these two asset classes over the last 100 years comes from the relationship between ten-year Baa bonds and ten-year U.S. Treasuries: since lower quality corporate bonds should always carry higher yields than like-maturity government bonds, corporate bond risk premiums should always be positive. Stock earnings yields, on the other hand, can drop below the yield on ten-year U.S. Treasuries, producing negative risk premiums (or risk penalties). It only makes sense that in an historical comparison of year-end risk premiums, bonds, which have only positive risk premiums, should outnumber stocks, which have both positive and negative risk premiums, depending on the market’s optimism or pessimism regarding future earnings growth.
It should be noted that over the prior 100-year history of negative stock risk premiums, all have occurred over the last 50 years. Based on year-end numbers, the first instance of a negative risk premium for the S&P 500 occurred in 1968 while the Vietnam War was in full rage and students and hippies were taking to the streets to protest the war. From 1968 onward, year-end risk premiums have been negative 32 times, prompted by such maladies as the “stagflation” of the ‘70s, hyperinflation, recessions (great and otherwise) and most bear markets. It is beyond the scope of this piece to explore why there were no negative equity earnings yields in the period before 1968—a period which included the Roaring Twenties, Prohibition, the Great Depression and World War II—but possible avenues for future investigation might include the complete abandonment of the gold standard in 1971 and the lessons learned (and not learned) during the 1970s bout of hyperinflation.
So, what causes equity risk premiums to turn negative? The simple answer is the combination of low earnings yields (high P/E ratios) and high interest rates. Over the last 50 years, there has been a high positive (+75%) correlation between equity earnings yields and the yields on ten-year Treasuries. In other words, it hasn’t taken much in the way of stress to push equity earnings yields lower than the yields on 10-year U.S. Treasuries: the average margin of 10-year Treasuries over equities in years with negative equity risk premiums was 1.4%.
We opened this discussion of risk premiums by mentioning that the subject appears to crop up during periods of stress in the economy and markets. Negative equity risk premiums are more of an effect rather than a cause of market stress. And, as we mentioned earlier, there’s no dearth of stress in the current “news of the day.” And despite the 250th anniversary of the founding of America and a quarter-end stock market rally that has set records in several equity indices, the current reading on the equity risk premium of the S&P 500 stands at a negative 1.2%.
Summary Q2 2026:
- Risk premiums are the extra returns one should expect for investing in a risky asset (stocks or long corporate bonds) over and above investing in a risk-free asset.
- Equity earnings yields are the inverse of stock P/E ratios (or E/P). The equity risk premium is the earnings yield minus a “risk-free” yield. For our purposes, we use the yield on ten-year U.S. Treasury bonds as the risk-free rate.
- Fixed income risk premiums are calculated as the difference in yield between ten-year low-investment-grade (Baa) corporate bonds and ten-year U.S. Treasuries.
- Contrary to expectations, over the last 100 years, year-end fixed income risk premiums have surpassed year-end equity risk premiums by a score of 55 to 45.
- Negative risk premiums are more of a sign of existing stress than a predictor of future stress.
Not Investment Advice or an Offer
This information is intended to assist investors. The information does not constitute investment advice or an offer to invest or to provide management services. It is not our intention to state, indicate, or imply in any manner that current or past results are indicative of future results or expectations. As with all investments, there are associated risks and you could lose money investing.




